Power Board
2008
397/398 - Company Law Board - Interpretation - Indian Company Law?
Many books were written on the subject of legal interpretation by the Courts and we have so many precedents on the same. In my opinion, the subject of interpretation is driven by the principle that the courts concerned will ascertain the legislative intention of a particular legislation or a provision and only in exceptional cases, the clear legislative intention is not considered when the same is opposed to public policy/constitutional provisions or the fundamental rights as enshrined in Part-III of Constitution of India. Because, the concerned legislature is the law-making body though we say that the judgment of a Constitutional Court becomes law unless overruled. The legislative intention of a particular legislation is gathered from the wording used, the objects, the title, the explanation clause etc. In my opinion, the subject of interpretation is based on the simple logic and we have so many judgments on the issue. Even today, when a case is represented before a Constitutional Court, it is seen that the judgments on the issue of interpretation are submitted though the subject is settled.
A proceeding under section 397/398 of the Companies Act, 1956 is complicated in my opinion, but, the stakes in many petitions under section 397/398 of the Act is more. A minority shareholder in the Company may trouble the clear majority in the Company though there is no illegality on the part of the Company or the majority by abusing section 397/398 of the Companies Act, 1956. On the same lines, a majority may deny the legitimate corporate rights of the minority shareholders and may rely on technicalities when the minority shareholders approach the Board seeking relief under section 397/398 of the Companies Act, 1956. Barring very few principles, the Courts have given Very Good judgments on section 397/398 of the Companies Act, 1956 and many principles are now settled. Despite the guidance from the Constitutional Courts through precedents, many feel that the Company Law Board often relies on technicalities while exercising powers under section 397/398 of the Companies Act, 1956. There can be an agreement between the Company and an outsider which is illegal, but, still, when the same illegal agreement is questioned by the minority before the Board, then, the majority may show the restrictions under section 402 of the Act and may rely on the principle that "disputed facts can not be decided by the Company as it follows summary procedure". The correct interpretation of provisions dealing with oppression and mismanagement with the ultimate object of protecting the rights of the minority or providing a relief is so important in my opinion. I do personally feel that we need much more clarity in the provisions dealing with oppression and mismanagement, but, I don't know as to how the proposed Company Bill addresses this. In my opinion, it is unlikely to see the clarity on the provisions dealing with oppression and mismanagement in the Companies Act, 1956 in the near future though we may be able to have "National Company Law Tribunal" and "National Company Law Appellate Tribunal". When it is observed practically as to how minority shareholders and even the majority are struggling for getting their disputes resolved and also proceedings before the Company Law Board at times, then, it is clear that the directions of the Hon'ble Supreme Court on the issue of challenge to Companies (Amendment) Act, 2002 are to be implemented in letter and spirit and finding loopholes and any dilution can not be tolerated.
I have recently read a judgment rendered by Hon'ble Dr.Justice D.Y.Chandrachud of Bombay High Court in Company Appeal No.51 of 2009 and I think that the manner in which the issue in the Appeal was dealt with and the observations can be of guidance on the issue as to how the provisions dealing with the oppression and mismanagement are to be interpreted. I have just extracted the important discussion/reference of the Hon'ble Bombay High Court hereunder. The judgment rendered below is basically on section 405 and 402 of the Companies Act, 1956, however, the analysis and the finding is laudable in my opinion.
High Court of Judicature at Bombay – Dr.Justice D.Y.Chandrachud – Company Appeal No.51 of 2009 – between Ravi Kiran Agarwal & Others Vs. Moolchand Shah S/o Mr. (Late) Sampat Raj & Others:
"13. Section 405 of the Act, deals with the power of the Company Law Board to implead additional Respondents to an application under Sections 397 or 398. Under section 405, if the Managing Director or any Director or a Manager of a company or any other person, has not been impleaded and such person applies to be added as a Respondent, the Company Law Board is empowered to pass an order added him as Respondent, if sufficient cause for doing so is established to the satisfaction of the Board. The Company Law Board in the present case inferred that the power to add or implead a party as a Respondent to an Application under Sections 397 or 398 is to add only those parties who are referred to in clause (d) and (e) of section 402. The Board applied the interpretative tool of ejusdem generis. The principle of ejusdem generis would have no application, where the Court is required to construe, two separate statutory provisions which operate in different fields. Section 402 illustrates the powers which can be exercised by the Company Law Board on an Application under Sections 397 and 398. Section 402 is not an exhaustive catalogue of the powers of the Board. Section 405 deals with the addition of parties. There is no reason on justification for confining the words "any other person" under Section 405 to those categories of persons who are elucidated in clause (e) of the Section 402. As a matter of first principle, it would be impermissible to do so. On an Application under Sections 397 and 398 the Board has, as already noted earlier, wide powers to pass orders as it thinks fit to bring to an end the matters of complained of and, under section 398(2), to even prevent the matters complained of or apprehended. The exercise of those wide powers, may in a given situation affect the interest of third parties. To hold that a third party liable to be affected by an order under SECTION 397 and 398, would not be entitled to be heard on the ground that, it does not fall within the description of ‘a person' in clause (e) of section 402 who has an agreement with the company would be fundamentally violative of the basic postulate of natural justice. Nothing, except a clear statutory provision to that effect should lead the court to adopt such a construction. If Parliament intended to contemplate the addition of only those persons who had Agreements with the Company, there was nothing to prevent the addition of those words. The words "any other person" in Section 405 are not restricted by a stipulation that such person must have an Agreement with the Company. Hence, the words "any other person" must be given their plain and natural meaning so as to include any person whose interest would be affected by an order that is sought in the application under SECTION 397 and 398. The Board misapplied the principle of ejusdem generis. The principle of ejusdem generis is that when particular words pertaining to a class category or genus are followed by general words, the general words are construed as limited to things of the same kind as those specified. The rule applies when i) The Statute contends an enumeration of specific words; ii) The subject of enumeration constitutes a class or category; iii) The class or category is not exhausted by the enumeration; iv) General terms follow upon the enumeration; and v) there is no indication of a different legislative intent. [G.P.Singh on the Principles of Statue Interpretation, 9th Edition page 420.] This principle can have no application in construing word "any other person" in section 405 which operates in a field untrammeled by section 402.
14. The Company Law Board has in the present case diluted its finding that the expression "any other person" under section 405 must be construed with reference to section 402(e) by holding that occasions may arise to implead other persons on the facts of each case. The Board noted that shareholders who are not parties may apply on the apprehension that, any relief granted would affect their interest or employees or creditors may also apply on the same ground. The Board held that notwithstanding the ‘strict' provisions of section 405, it may have to use it discretion in deciding on the basis of the facts of each case, where the application for impleadment has shown sufficient cause to be impleaded as a Respondent. The residual discretion which the Board assumes to it, would itself indicate that the provisions of Section 405 cannot be construed in the manner in which they were construed in the earlier part of the judgment. The interpretation that has been placed by the Board on the provisions of section 405 is erroneous and has to be disapproved. The power of the Board under section 405 to implead any other person, is a wide power which is conditioned, only by the satisfaction of the Board, that there is sufficient cause for doing so. Where the relief that is sought in the application under Sections 397 or 398 is liable to affect the interest of a third party, an order of impleadment would be warranted. The impleadment of the party may be considered necessary, or in the facts of a case, proper in order to enable the Board to render a full, final and complete adjudication of the dispute. By its very nature, the power cannot be restricted to predefined categories and must be exercised in order to advance the underlying purpose and object of the provisions of Sections 397 and 398."
"18. The Appeal before this Court arises under section 10F of the COMPANIES ACT 1956 and is confined to a question of law. For the reasons already indicated, this court has come to the conclusion that the interpretation that has been by the Board on the provisions of section 405 is erroneous. Having decided the question of law relating to the interpretation of the section 405, it would be, but appropriate for this Court to remit the proceedings back to the Company Law Board for a decision afresh, on the application for impleadment. The Board is a primary fact finding authority and should be left to determine the question of impleadment in the light of the interpretation that has been placed by this Court on the provisions of section 405. Before concluding, it would be necessary to observe that in adverting to the rival submissions, which have been urged on behalf of the parties in regard to the effect of the MOU, this Court has had no occasion to render any finding of fact on the effect of the MOU or on the entitlement of the Appellants thereunder. In order to facilitate a fresh determination, the impugned order of the Company Law Board dated 13th April 2009 is set aside."
Note: I views expressed are my personal and based on my own understanding of the issue and I have no intention whatsoever to make an unwarranted comment on any institution.
About the Author
V.DURGA RAO, Advocate, Madras High Court.
Email: vdrao_attorney@yahoo.co.in
http://indiancorporatelaws.blogspot.com/
Electric Skateboards at Powerboard.com - Your Electric Skateboard Power Board Super Store
 |
 power supply unit board PCA046FD 011 P R for Haier L22R3W L22K3W $24.99 Time Remaining: 29d 10h 28m Buy It Now for only: $24.99 Buy It Now |
 PDP 504CMX Power Supply Board PCB2378 A06 124668G $35.00 Time Remaining: 3h 8m Buy It Now for only: $45.00 Buy It Now |
 Samsung BN94 00622A Power Supply board $30.00 Time Remaining: 7h 1m Buy It Now for only: $50.00 Buy It Now |
 NEW Samsung LN40D550K1F Power Board BN44 00440B I40F01 BHS $29.97 Time Remaining: 4d 21h 20m Buy It Now for only: $29.97 Buy It Now |
 Panasonic TXN P1BJTU Power Supply board $35.00 Time Remaining: 7h 1m |
 Samsung power supply SMPS IP board BN44 00199B LN40A330J1 $49.00 Time Remaining: 9h 3m Buy It Now for only: $69.00 Buy It Now |
 RCA 275553 Power Board 40 1PL37C PWE1XG $49.00 Time Remaining: 4d 6h 3m Buy It Now for only: $49.00 Buy It Now |
 ELEMENT ELCHS321 POWER SUPPLY BOARD RSAG8201411 ROH $84.00 Time Remaining: 10h 52m Buy It Now for only: $94.00 Buy It Now |
 Proscan Power Supply Board 123882 RSAG78201357 ROH for 55LC55S240V69 $149.95 Time Remaining: 29d 11h 42m Buy It Now for only: $149.95 Buy It Now |
 SOYO TV BOARD 95PS 012 POWER BRD $50.00 Time Remaining: 14h Buy It Now for only: $55.00 Buy It Now |
 Vizio 0940 0000 2270 Power Supply Unit Board VP42HDTV10A VP423HDTV10A $71.98 Time Remaining: 15h 25m |
 NEW Acer Aspire 4220 4320 4520 4520Z 4720 4720Z DC Power Jack Usb Board 00889 $9.90 Time Remaining: 22d 17h 33m Buy It Now for only: $9.90 Buy It Now |
 SAMSUNG BN44 00438A POWER SUPPLY BOARD $39.00 Time Remaining: 20h 52m Buy It Now for only: $45.00 Buy It Now |
 New DC Power Jack USB Port Board Compaq Presario F500 F700 V6000 V6500 V6600 90W $13.75 Time Remaining: 10h 19m Buy It Now for only: $13.75 Buy It Now |
 MITS LT 40153 POWER SUPPLY BOARD $40.00 Time Remaining: 20h 52m Buy It Now for only: $50.00 Buy It Now |
 55 Inch Samsung Plasma Power Supply Board PSLF311B01A Working TV $148.00 Time Remaining: 1d 4h 21m |
 Dynex RSAG78201673 ROH Ver F Power Supply TV Board $70.00 Time Remaining: 29d 10h 7m Buy It Now for only: $70.00 Buy It Now |
 Vizio E420VA Power Supply Board $29.95 Time Remaining: 1d 6h 4m Buy It Now for only: $35.00 Buy It Now |
 Sharp DPS 208BP RDENCA354WJQZ Power Supply TV Board $50.00 Time Remaining: 29d 9h 43m Buy It Now for only: $50.00 Buy It Now |
 Vizio VO420E power supply board part 0500 0407 0750 $34.00 Time Remaining: 1d 8h 18m Buy It Now for only: $38.00 Buy It Now |
 Power Board for SHARP LCD TV Model LC 46SB57U 100 Working $39.95 Time Remaining: 1d 8h 42m Buy It Now for only: $49.00 Buy It Now |
 OEM DELL WXHDY INSPIRON 15R M5010 N5010 CN 0WXHDY I O USB AC DC POWER JACK BOARD $24.95 Time Remaining: 5d 22h 58m Buy It Now for only: $24.95 Buy It Now |
 Vizio VX37L HDTV10A Part Number DPS 247AP Power Board $29.99 Time Remaining: 1d 12h 13m |
 New DC Power Jack with Board for Dell Inspiron 1545 484AQ03011 484AQ03021 $9.89 Time Remaining: 7d 23h 38m Buy It Now for only: $9.89 Buy It Now |
 RCA 46 LCD TV 46LA45RQ Parts Power supply Main board etc $99.99 Time Remaining: 1d 14h 11m Buy It Now for only: $129.00 Buy It Now |
 Magnavox Power Supply Board 3138 103 62942 $67.50 Time Remaining: 1d 14h 32m Buy It Now for only: $75.00 Buy It Now |
 Samsung LN T4671F LN T4671F S LN T4671FX XAA Board IP 321135A Power Supply $79.00 Time Remaining: 29d 7h 40m Buy It Now for only: $79.00 Buy It Now |
 Samsung 2008 Tv LN52A550 parts Lot power supply main board t con lcd 55 inch $39.99 Time Remaining: 1d 14h 35m |
 Philips TV Power Board DLP2K6 OEM Part 3139 128 77931 See Models Below $40.00 Time Remaining: 1d 17h 54m Buy It Now for only: $50.00 Buy It Now |
 New 42 Vizio YSUS Power Board 6871QYH053B $99.99 Time Remaining: 29d 9h 7m Buy It Now for only: $99.99 Buy It Now |
 Samsung BN94 0622H Power Board w Plug Calculated Ship Worldwide No Reserve $89.99 Time Remaining: 1d 18h 46m |
 08530 2 08530 1 00835 Dell 1545 DR1 Charger Board DC Power octagonal Jack USB $9.89 Time Remaining: 1d 22h 22m Buy It Now for only: $9.89 Buy It Now |
 Vizio E3d470VX Power Board 0500 0412 1220 $59.95 Time Remaining: 1d 23h 12m Buy It Now for only: $84.95 Buy It Now |
 Zenith DLP Z445Z80 Power Supply Board $49.99 Time Remaining: 2d 1h 22m |
 HP CQ50 CQ60 G60 Power Button Board 484H503011 TESTED $14.77 Time Remaining: 29d 8h 18m Buy It Now for only: $14.77 Buy It Now |
 Philips LJ44 00101b PS 424 PH Power Supply Board $29.01 Time Remaining: 2d 8h 1m |
 New DELL INSPIRON 15R M5010 N5010 AC DC Power Jack Board 484HH020SB DG15 PB19A $24.99 Time Remaining: 21d 17h 17m Buy It Now for only: $24.99 Buy It Now |
 samsung m ln s3251d or lns3251d power supply BOARD p BN96 03057A $30.00 Time Remaining: 2d 8h 43m |
 Samsung BN44 00201A Power Supply Board for 52 LN52A750R1FXZA $75.00 Time Remaining: 2d 9h 37m |
 Acer Aspire 3680 3050 5050 Power Board DC Jack USB PB02 $7.83 Time Remaining: 28d 18h 24m Buy It Now for only: $7.83 Buy It Now |
 Panasonic 813MSS Sub Power Supply Board TC P65S2 Plasma HDTV TV 1080P Part $20.00 Time Remaining: 2d 10h 5m Buy It Now for only: $40.00 Buy It Now |
 Dell Inspiron 1545 DC Power Jack DR1 Charger Usb Board $9.89 Time Remaining: 25d 9h 42m Buy It Now for only: $9.89 Buy It Now |
 Panasonic NPX813MS1 Power Supply Board TC P65S2 Plasma HDTV TV 1080P Part $35.00 Time Remaining: 2d 10h 6m Buy It Now for only: $75.00 Buy It Now |
 LG 6871VPMB17B POWER SUPPLY BOARD $39.99 Time Remaining: 2d 10h 12m Buy It Now for only: $49.99 Buy It Now |
 Asus K52F K52 USB DC Power Jack board K52JR 3DKJ3DB0000 60 NXMDC1000 w Battery $45.95 Time Remaining: 10d 8h 22m Buy It Now for only: $45.95 Buy It Now |
 RCA 42PA30RQ Power Supply Board LJ44 00187A PSPF321501C $77.00 Time Remaining: 2d 10h 54m Buy It Now for only: $87.00 Buy It Now |
 SAMSUNG LN52B530P7F POWER SUPPLY BOARD BN44 00267B $59.89 Time Remaining: 29d 12h 52m Buy It Now for only: $59.89 Buy It Now |
 Panasonic TC L42E3 42 lcd TV Parts power supply main board etc $99.99 Time Remaining: 2d 13h 44m Buy It Now for only: $129.99 Buy It Now |
 SAMSUNG TV LCD POWER BOARD $49.95 Time Remaining: 2d 14h Buy It Now for only: $59.95 Buy It Now |
 ORIGINAL DELL INSPIRON 1545 DC POWER JACK CHARGER BOARD $9.89 Time Remaining: 26d 17h 40m Buy It Now for only: $9.89 Buy It Now |
 LG MAIN POWER BOARD 6709V00001A $35.00 Time Remaining: 2d 16h 32m Buy It Now for only: $65.00 Buy It Now |
 New Genuine Acer Aspire 3050, 3680, 3690, 5050, 5570, 5570z, 5580, TravelMate 2480, 3260, 3270 Series Power Board w/ Dc Jack & USB Port Sale Price: $34.99  Eligible for free shipping!Availability: Usually ships in 1-2 business days See Reviews For This Product DescriptionThis is a brand new genuine part. The board you will receive is revision F which replaces revisions C, D and E. We are not responsible for any damage caused by installing this part incorrectly.  |
 Stanley PC1A09 100 Watt Power Inverter with USB Power Outlet Sale Price: $24.99 Eligible for free shipping!Availability: Usually ships in 24 hours See Reviews For This Product DescriptionStanley 100-Watt Inverter - Auto has 100 continuous watts of power, a 110 power outlet and a USB power outlet. It features silent running technology so avoids the annoying fan noise. This inverter has 3 positions for versatility and a dual direction plug interface. |
 Samsung OEM BN44-00161A SPMS POWER SUPPLY Board PCB Sale Price: $125.94 Eligible for free shipping!Availability: Usually ships in 1-2 business days See Reviews For This Product DescriptionSMPS-PDP TV;HPS4253, |
 Yamaha PA130MM 120 Volt Keyboard AC Power Adaptor List Price: Sale Price: Too low to display Eligible for free shipping!Availability: Usually ships in 24 hours See Reviews For This Product DescriptionYamaha PA130 Power Adapter |
 The Complete Vision Board Kit: Using the Power of Intention and Visualization to Achieve Your Dreams List Price: Sale Price: $16.49 You save: $8.50 (34%) Eligible for free shipping!Availability: Usually ships in 24 hours See Reviews For This Product DescriptionA vision board is a powerful tool that anyone can use to shape an ideal future through the power of intention and visualization. Learning how to vividly imagine your desired results--attracting your perfect soul mate, radiant health, abundant career opportunities, or building personal and community relationships to give back--is the first step on the path to making them happen... |
 Gator Cases G-BONE Bone Pedal Board with Carry Bag & Power Supply List Price: Sale Price: $59.95 You save: $50.04 (45%) Eligible for free shipping!Availability: Usually ships in 24 hours See Reviews For This Product DescriptionMolded PE Pedal Board & Carry Case |
 Power Grid List Price: Sale Price: $34.16 You save: $10.83 (24%) Eligible for free shipping!Availability: Usually ships in 24 hours See Reviews For This Product DescriptionPower Grid is the updated release of the Friedemann Friese crayon game Funkenschlag. The latest cooperative publishing effort from Friedemann Friese and Rio Grande Games, removes the crayon aspect from network building in the original edition while retaining the fluctuating commodities market like McMulti and an auction round intensity reminiscent of The Princes of Florence... |
 Power Up Charging Stand for Wii Fit List Price: Sale Price: $19.99 You save: $20.00 (50%) Eligible for free shipping!Availability: Usually ships in 24 hours See Reviews For This Product DescriptionKeep your Wii Fit Balance Board neatly stored and full of energy with the Power Up Charging Stand from Mad Catz. Simply remove the battery cover and batteries from your Balance Board and replace them with the included rechargeable battery pack for hours of continuous gameplay... |
 New Genuine Acer Aspire 4220, 4220G, 4320, 4520, 4520G, 4720, 4720G, 4720Z Power Board w/ Dc Jack, USB Ports & Power Button Sale Price: $49.99 Eligible for free shipping!Availability: Usually ships in 1-2 business days See Reviews For This Product DescriptionThis is a brand new genuine part. We are not responsible for any damage caused by installing this part incorrectly. |
 Bulletin Board Power: Bridges to Lifelong Learning List Price: See Reviews For This Product DescriptionDo you want your bulletin boards to get noticed? This invaluable guide will get you through several years of attention-grabbing bulletin boards! With hands-on directions for 72 different bulletin boards, this book is a gold mine for every educator and librarian! |
Computer News
Comment